Education

TV subtitles as an aid to literacy: What does the research say?

Jack Black is probably best known in educational circles for playing a renegade substitute teacher in School of Rock. But the Hollywood star has made a more conventional foray into education by backing the use of TV subtitles to improve child literacy. Stephen Fry and the World Literacy Foundation also want parents to use their TV remotes to get children reading. So, could this simple click of a button be a solution to boost pupils’ reading skills? AQA’s resident expert on language teaching, Dr Katy Finch, casts her eye over the research to see whether it stacks up.

Date11/04/24

AuthorDr Katy Finch

Photo: Immo Wegmann/Unsplash

Reading and writing form the building blocks of education and dominate primary school teaching.

But despite educators’ relentless focus on developing these skills in every child, the most recent SATs results show many still struggle and more than one in four do not meet expected standards.

It is not just schools that are concerned about the literacy issue

Celebrities ranging from Queen Camilla to Dolly Parton have launched literacy campaigns to support work done in schools.

The latest A-lister to get involved is School of Rock star Jack Black, who posted a video in support of Essex-based campaign group ‘Turn On The Subtitles’ (TotS).

What is the literacy campaign Jack Black is supporting?

TotS proposes turning on subtitles when children are watching TV as a way of improving their literacy.

This way, children can match the written words to the sounds, the visuals and the context. Neat huh?

It seems a simple and elegant solution, but does it actually work?

What do we know about the use of television subtitles to boost literacy?

Let’s take a look at the wealth of research carried out over the last three decades in various contexts and locations across the globe.

In 2010 researchers running a small US study, found that young readers (aged 7-9 years-old) who watched a series of children’s TV shows with subtitles could recognise, read, and understand more words from the programmes that those who watched without subtitles.

More recently, literacy experts working with low-income families in India used eye-tracking tools to discover that children who struggled to read engaged more with subtitles when watching simple stories being told.

Another study reviewed 30 years’ worth of research into the issue.

More than 100 of these studies, many of which involved adults and college students as well as school pupils, documented that subtitles improve comprehension of, attention to and memory for the video content.

So, there you go, it looks like we have an answer to the literacy issue.

Subtitling video content can bridge the gap for children who struggle to engage with text but watch television.

But wait a moment.

Has the case for using subtitles to improve literacy been made?

Before we send out the party invitations, let's be sure about what we're talking about here.

A deeper examination of the data reveals a little more nuance to consider.

Who actually benefits from using TV subtitles as a literacy aid?

Firstly, it is not all children who were seen to benefit from subtitles.

In the 2010 US study mentioned earlier, the effects were greater (but not in a statistically significant way) for those who were lower attaining readers to begin with.

Word recognition improved most for children ‘at risk’ of not acquiring good reading skills (eg from lower socio-economic backgrounds or with parents who have low literacy/education levels).

And while their word recognition improved, their general comprehension did not in the same way.

That shows that while subtitling boosted children’s ability to recognise some of those words later on, it did not enhance their understanding of the words’ meaning to the same extent.

Secondly, the children in the Indian study were engaged when the content was simple and easy to follow but started to drift off when stories became more complex.

That might indicate that the benefits of subtitles work at a low level but erode as the subject becomes more taxing.

And finally, the researcher carrying out the literature review noted that many of the positive studies found subtitles were of particular benefit to children and adults learning to read and those watching content in their non-native language.

In conclusion...

It appears that the largest benefits come for those children who do not otherwise have regular access to printed text or do not have parents able to read to them regularly (whether that is due to their own literacy levels or that they may not read in the language of the child’s education).

So, while reading subtitles should not replace reading books, it may be a great tool to help some children have greater access to reading at home.

Assessment

Assessing oracy: Is Comparative Judgement the answer?

Oracy skills are vital to success in school and life. And yet, for many children, opportunities to develop them are missed. Educationalists are engaging in a growing debate about where oracy fits into the school system. Labour has put it at the heart of its plans to improve social mobility and an independent commission is looking at how it is taught in the classroom. This renewed focus on oracy means it is more important than ever that teachers have a way to reliably assess and understand their students’ attainment and progression. Amanda Moorghen of oracy education charity Voice 21 explains how Comparative Judgement can help with that and why it may be a game changer.

Education

TV subtitles as an aid to literacy: What does the research say?

Data Analysis

What is left behind now education’s Data Wave has receded?

Is data the solution to all education’s issues? About a decade ago the prevailing wisdom said it was. Advocates of this Data Wave argued that harvesting internal statistics would help schools solve issues such as teacher accountability and attainment gaps. As with all waves, after crashing onto the beach they recede, leaving space for another to roll in. In this blog, teacher, author and data analyst Richard Selfridge looks at the legacy of the Data Wave to see what schools can take from it.

International Approaches

Finland & PISA – A fall from grace but still a high performer?

Finland was once recognised as one of the most successful educational systems in the world. At the turn of the millennium, it topped the PISA rankings in reading, maths and science. But by 2012, decline set in. The last set of results showed performances in maths, reading and science were at an all-time low. In this blog Dr Jonathan Doherty of Leeds Trinity University outlines some reasons that may account for the slide.

Briefing

PISA, TIMSS and PIRLS: What actually are they and what do they tell us?

According to the latest PISA results, England’s science scores are still on a downward trajectory that started a decade ago. Yet TIMSS, another respected study, has science performances rising. Which of them is right? Is one more valid than the other? In this blog AQi examines three International Large-Scale Assessments and finds that, although they may look the same from a distance, get up close and you’ll find they are very different beasts.

Adaptive Assessment

Adaptive Assessment: A missing ingredient in the resit recipe?

The number of students resitting their maths GCSE is growing, but the proportion getting a grade 4 or higher is falling. This situation is not only dispiriting for the young people striving to get the qualifications they need, but also for the teachers working hard to help them. How can outcomes for this cohort be improved? Bart Crisp, associate director at the Centre for the Use of Research and Evidence in Education, thinks adaptive assessment may be part of the solution.

SEND

Student success: Every milestone matters

Baroness Morgan is calling for students to be given ‘self-belief’ lessons as a way of developing their characters and preparing them for the future. She is not the first to notice that a student’s sense of their own ability and their level of success are part of a virtuous circle. But how can teachers get the snowball rolling for students with SEND or in alternative provision? In this blog, former headteacher, John Tomsett, pulls out a swimming certificate he earned more than half a century ago to use as an inspiration for others.

Assessment

Progress 8 – How much can it flex?

Progress 8 has come in for criticism in recent months for the way it combines with the Ebacc to skew schools’ focus towards academic subjects at the expense of creative and technical options. Both Labour and a Lords committee have called for reform to boost uptake of declining subjects such as D&T, dance and drama. In the second of two blogs looking at Progress 8, AQi examines whether the accountability measure could be realigned to address these concerns and if so, how could that be done?

Assessment

Progress 8 – Schools’ flexible friend?

Eight years after Progress 8 came into existence it is facing calls to be updated. Some say reforming the schools accountability measure can halt the decline in take up of the arts, while others want it to boost numbers taking vocational and technical subjects. Are its shoulders broad enough to take on such a load? In the first of two blogs on Progress 8, AQi looks at how it came into being, what problems it was designed to solve and whether it is flexible enough to be reformed.

Assessment

2023: A year in review

As we wrap up a year full of exciting developments in education, it is the perfect time to take stock of what has gone on. In this blog, editor of AQi, Anil Dawar, reflects on some of his highlights for 2023.

Download a PDF version.

Download a copy of this content to your device as a PDF file. We generate PDF versions for the convenience of offline reading, but we recommend sharing this link if you'd like to send it to someone else.

TV subtitles as an aid to literacy: What does the research say?

It is not just schools that are concerned about the literacy issue

What is the literacy campaign Jack Black is supporting?

What do we know about the use of television subtitles to boost literacy?

Has the case for using subtitles to improve literacy been made?

Who actually benefits from using TV subtitles as a literacy aid?

In conclusion...

Assessing oracy: Is Comparative Judgement the answer?

TV subtitles as an aid to literacy: What does the research say?

What is left behind now education’s Data Wave has receded?

Finland & PISA – A fall from grace but still a high performer?

PISA, TIMSS and PIRLS: What actually are they and what do they tell us?

Adaptive Assessment: A missing ingredient in the resit recipe?

Student success: Every milestone matters

Progress 8 – How much can it flex?

Progress 8 – Schools’ flexible friend?

2023: A year in review

Join the conversation on Twitter

Download a PDF version.

Sign up to our newsletter